The Glass Castle by Jeannette Walls (nonfiction)
Whenever you think your parents are kooky or whenever you think your life is tough, you need to read this book. Walls' parents were clearly gifted, intelligent people who loved their children. But they each had serious character flaws that prevented them from being unselfish. They are probably the most selfish two parents I have ever read about.
It's a miracle that Walls and her siblings even survived their childhood. You get a whole new appreciation of what alcoholism does to a family. But it's more than just an alcoholic father that creates the childhood that Walls experiences. Her mother doesn't fit into a neat category either.
From the blurb on the book jacket, I expected to read about an alcoholic parent and the strife that ensued because of it. I was not prepared for Rex and Mary Rose Walls. There were so many scenes that caused me to hold my breath and wonder how those children lived--what kind of a mother would suggest to her child to just cut off the maggot-y part of a week old, unrefrigerated ham and tell her that some people were too picky? What kind of parents would lock their 4 children (one an infant) into the back of a windowless U-Haul trailer and drive for 16 hours without checking on them? What kind of parents would feed their children only popcorn and let them sleep in boxes while refusing to sell property worth over a million dollars? What kind of parents would. . . well, you could finish that sentence a zillion different ways.
Walls does not try to explain her parents. She just presents them in a voice that reflects her vision as a child. She loves them. She is not critical of them and is pretty matter of fact about their behavior. You can appreciate the free spirit that her father was, and the creative artist her mother was. Her father "gives" her Venus as a Christmas present one year, and it is clear she adores him. However, as Walls grows older, her voice changes to one a teeny bit more critical, mostly because of the ruined dreams she and her siblings are subjected to. She is still conflicted--how can you disapprove of your own parents' choice about living?
It's a miracle that Walls and her siblings even survived their childhood. You get a whole new appreciation of what alcoholism does to a family. But it's more than just an alcoholic father that creates the childhood that Walls experiences. Her mother doesn't fit into a neat category either.
From the blurb on the book jacket, I expected to read about an alcoholic parent and the strife that ensued because of it. I was not prepared for Rex and Mary Rose Walls. There were so many scenes that caused me to hold my breath and wonder how those children lived--what kind of a mother would suggest to her child to just cut off the maggot-y part of a week old, unrefrigerated ham and tell her that some people were too picky? What kind of parents would lock their 4 children (one an infant) into the back of a windowless U-Haul trailer and drive for 16 hours without checking on them? What kind of parents would feed their children only popcorn and let them sleep in boxes while refusing to sell property worth over a million dollars? What kind of parents would. . . well, you could finish that sentence a zillion different ways.
Walls does not try to explain her parents. She just presents them in a voice that reflects her vision as a child. She loves them. She is not critical of them and is pretty matter of fact about their behavior. You can appreciate the free spirit that her father was, and the creative artist her mother was. Her father "gives" her Venus as a Christmas present one year, and it is clear she adores him. However, as Walls grows older, her voice changes to one a teeny bit more critical, mostly because of the ruined dreams she and her siblings are subjected to. She is still conflicted--how can you disapprove of your own parents' choice about living?
Comments
They are really smart people, and the children I think are pretty smart for their ages.
And at times I agreed with the way situations were handled, and at other times, which was most of the time I might add, i thought it was cruel.
Such as the time Jeanette was holding Quixote the cat, and they were driving down the road and Quixote didnt like it so Rex Walls took it and threw it out the window. Or the time where the cats got overpopulated and Rex put them in bags and tossed them into the pond.
Yet a majority of the ones who beg with their signs arent homeless. Because you have to have money to beg, there is a lisence that costs about $150 to stand out there and beg. So dont feel bad when you dont give them money, because it most likely is going towards alchohol and tobacco. I know im getting a little off topic, but i think its wrong for the people to beg when they arent homeless, because there are so many out there that are homeless out there not begging.
I have noticed as Jeanette grows older she realizes her dad is full of broken promises, and begins to realize he might be a helpless drunk like a lot of people have said to her before. I also think the mom is strait up lazy and dosent care if her kids dont eat or stay warm during the winter. Because if she did, she would get the husband in line or leave him, get welfare, and spend her paycheck on items the family needs to get by.
I completely agree with Jessica and Courtney about homeless people.
And I too have come to realize that dont have much compassion for them.
Also Jeanette was very descriptive in her writing. Countless times I closed my eyes while reading to visualize and feel what Jeanette was saying. Her writing allows you to become appart of the family and know what it feels like to be in her position.
Despite her father's akwardness as a father, Rex Walls did show affection to his children. The time he was blessed with a somewhat steady income, he bought all the kids new bikes(pg. 98). He surprised them after work one day. Jeannette couldn't believe her eyes. You can really tell she is thankful. If these children were given 5 cents they would know how to put it to good use.
I also like how Jeannette's father calls her "Mountain Goat". There is a special bond between father and daughter here. Page 99 is the reference I thought best to explain. I can picture Rex kneeling down to watch his daughter's anxious eyes as she stares at her new gift. It doesn't matter what he has done, Jeannette really loves her father and she shows that throughout the book.
This also goes for the way they choose to deal with circumstances. Brian and Jeannette could have whined and complained about numerous things in their life, but instead they were always out exploring or making up new games to keep each other busy. I wonder if they would still be this way-wild imaginations, and thankful attitudes- if they grew up differently...Would they be "soft"? Because their shells are pretty tough to break as young kids.
Jeanettte Walls makes me want to read more and more of her books. Like Meg has said, I've also never read a book with this style of writing. It's truley different, and I love it!
I was also amazed when the parents told the children they like living the homeless life. But the Wall's Parents were always a bit weird, so at the sametime it dosent surprise me.
I really enjoyed this book, great choice Mrs. Colley!
I also agree with the many that said Jeanette's style of writing pulls you in, and keeps you interested so you want to read more.
There is some inherent bias in writing a memoir, though. The author remembers things as she experienced them, not necessarily as they were. In my family we call that "mis-remembering." I wonder how her father would tell the story of skeedaddling her out of the hospital? It would probably include his suspicion that they wanted to take his kid away from him. Remember the fourth child? Wonder what she remembers about these events? Hey, that would be a good writing assignment . . . asking you to write the same event from a different person's perspective. . . H-m-m. Don't worry; I'm not going to do that!
Theory doesn't always carry the day, which is why adults understand things that children do not. The world just doesn't work like the rule book says it should. Gravity is about the only rule I've seen that has never been broken. (OK, so I'm not a scientist.) I love that line from the book, too. It reveals how intelligent Rex was, both in academics (atoms/protons) and in relationships with other people (he knows how she felt about the rock collection).
When Alyssa said she liked that Rex Walls always told stories, I realized I liked that too. There was a soft spot somewhere inside of me for Jeannette's father, but I didn't know where. My grandpa used to tell me stories all the time! Rex was the same way, entertaining people with a good anecdote. My grandfather was nothing like Rex, but when people often have a good story to tell and you can take something out of what they are saying, I admire them for that. I'm sure deep down, Rex Walls had good intentions! We saw those throughout the book when he was sober...or somewhat sober.
I just want to add in, my belated grandfather used to tell me stories of Italy all the time. And to this day, I remember them, and I cherish them. You never realize how great a good story is, until you lose the one who tells it, and I believe Jeannette realized that when Rex died of a heartattack. I look back everyday on those stories. And I love them more and more.
I also think that not just anyone can write a memoir, Walls is very comfortable with what has happened in her past and she isn't afraid to write about it.
I agree with Meg from July 22nd, Rex Walls did have good intentions even though most of the time he didn't show it. He had a very special way of telling stories, whether they were true or not, he knew how to keep someone entertained and wanting to hear more.
I also didn't understand their reasoning for not moving to Pheonix right away when they knew they had money and a house there.
However, it was very sentimental when she left Welch. Her mother didn't come to the train station to say goodbye, but her father was waiting for her on the front steps the morning she left(pg. 240). This shows a side of Rex Walls that we normally didn't see in the book. Jeannette said she realized he shaved for her. Something that small meant so much to her..and us as readers, since we know his personality. He even gave her his jackknife. Even though his daughter was leaving, I think Rex Walls was proud of her and sad to see her go at the same time. Perhaps he was reminiscing on the days he had the chance to get out and never did..just like Jeannette thought on page 241. She says, "I wondered if he was hoping his favorite girl would come back, or if he was hoping that, unlike him, she would make it out for good." Whatever he was thinking or feeling, this part of the book was very touching.
Jeannette went swiftly through the end of the book, so we don't have as much information as the rest. Hopefully Maureen is recovering and starting a healthy life in New York. Maybe seeing how Lori, Brian and Jeannette ended up will show Maureen she can get out of the rut and she has loving people who will help her.
Anyways, I found this book to be very intriguing and at times I found it extremely hard to believe. I could not wrap my mind around their way of life at all. The whole time I found myself getting so confused as to how anyone, much less a parent, could just refuse to live a normal and stable life.
Anyways, in response to your question about her writing style and how she gets us to have a soft spot for her father... I think it is because she writes so honestly. More honest than I have ever read. She truly told her story as she experienced it and held nothing back.Because of this, we as readers developed the relationship with her father that she had. She explained her feelings toward him so that we understood it completely which is not an easy feat. She shared all of her thoughts about her father and made sense out of him. She made her father, "the town drunk", likable to an audience of people who have never met him. Not everyone can do that.
Also, sorry I haven't posted in so long! I was traveling, then I had band camp, and then I got really sick, and now here I am! I'm really sorry I missed such great comments and discussion!
Anyway, about the turnout of Maureen. I feel as though she was predisposed to have it the hardest. I mean all of her siblings moved out and she had nothing but her parents to depend on, who were never really there. When you are a child you need your parents to support and nurture you through everything.Since Maureen grew up with them when it was the hardest, that lifstyle did the most damage. But even besides that, Maureen could have just had a weaker personality. In other words she might not have delt with things as well at Jeanette and her brother did.
I think that Maureen turned out differently than the others because of the age difference. I think maybe she felt trapped by her parents and siblings. Like many of the other posts have said, she followed in her parents footsteps. Which wasn't a good choice but she didn't exactly know better, she couldn't relate to her siblings the way they related to each other. So she didn't have their support to break free from how her parents acted. When they lived in Welch she was never with her family, and with other families which was good for her then. But when she went to New York she didn't have those kind of friends that she could escape to. Once her parents moved up there, she just kind of snapped.
I think that all of us can relate to the book in someway. Seeing as how Jeannette went through so many things that a lot of people have gone through or are going through.
If the Walls' parents could have spoiled their kids, I think they would have given them equality. Especially Rex, he was not for treating any child differently than the other(even though we knew he did have a very special place in his heart for Jeannette). Like Mrs. Colley said, Jeannette could have written The Glass Castle from the way she saw things. So this is the way we view their family-through Jeannette's eyes. Lori could have felt that Rex made her feel like the most loved, or Brian. Even though every kid should feel that love from their parent[s]. We know the parents had to love their kids- under the odd circumstances of their lives- but Maureen just grew up in a different era(if you will) than the other children and saw things differently. She never knew about skedaddling, or Erma, or traveling in the moving truck for 16 hours. I completely agree with Mrs. Colley when she says, yes this is a memoir, but it is how YOU yourself remember the journey.
I don't think I will ever be able to fathom that. How can she still love him as a father if he tried to "sell" her off to some stranger?
That part of her life really depicts how horrible of a person he was. I understand that his mother was sexually abusive (which is apparent during the family visit) but that does not give him a right to do such a disgusting thing.
When Lori was going to leave for New York Rex stole all the money she had been saving up to buy alcohol. As well as breaking the bust that Lori had been working on for weeks. But even on top of that, when Lori eventually goes to New York, Mary is jealous that it she wasn't the one going.
It just makes me so mad that parents could treat thier children that way.
They are so selfish and they hurt the people that love them.